zuai-logo

Selecting an Experimental Design

Isabella Lopez

Isabella Lopez

8 min read

Listen to this study note

Study Guide Overview

This study guide covers experimental design for the AP Statistics exam, focusing on completely randomized, blocking, and matched pairs designs. It explains how and when to use each design, provides practice problems and solutions, highlights common mistakes, and offers memory aids and final exam tips. It also includes practice multiple-choice and free-response questions with answers and scoring guidelines.

Experimental Design: Your Guide to AP Stats Success ๐Ÿš€

Hey there, future AP Stats superstar! Let's break down experimental design so you're ready to rock the exam. Remember, choosing the right design is key to getting valid results. Let's dive in!

The Big Three Experimental Designs

These are the bread and butter of experimental design. Know them well!


Completely Randomized Design

Key Concept

In a completely randomized design, experimental units are assigned to treatments randomly. Each unit has an equal chance of being in any treatment group. It's the simplest design, great for when you don't suspect other lurking variables.

  • How it works: Think of drawing names from a hat. Each participant has an equal chance of being assigned to any group.
  • When to use it: When you have a fairly homogenous group and no specific variables you need to control for.
  • Example: Testing the effectiveness of a new fertilizer on plants. Randomly assign plants to different fertilizer groups.

Blocking Design

Key Concept

In a blocking design, you first group your experimental units into blocks based on a variable that might affect the response. Then, you randomize within each block.

  • How it works: Like sorting socks by color before matching them. You group similar units together, then randomize treatments within those groups.
  • When to use it: When you know a variable (the blocking variable) could influence your results. This helps reduce variability within treatment groups.
  • Example: Testing a new drug, but you know age affects drug response. Block by age group, then randomize treatment within each age group.

Matched Pairs Design

Key Concept

A matched pairs design is a special type of blocking where you pair up similar units (or use the same unit twice) and then randomly assign treatments within each pair.

  • How it works: Think of twins. You pair them up because they're very similar, then give each twin a different treatment. Or, you could give the same person two different treatments over time.
  • When to use it: When you have two treatments and want to compare them on very similar units. Great for reducing variability due to individual differences.
  • Example: Testing two different running shoes. Have the same runner try both shoes, or pair runners with similar running styles and have each runner try one shoe.

Exam Tip

Key Difference: Completely randomized designs are the simplest, but blocking and matched pairs designs help control for variability, giving you more precise results.


Practice Problems

Let's apply what we've learned with some practice problems. Remember, understanding these scenarios is key to success on the exam!

Problem 1: Completely Randomized Design

(1) A researcher wants to test a new teaching method on 50 high school students. Describe how to set up a completely randomized design.

Answer
  • Compile a list of all 50 students.
  • Use a random number generator or similar method to randomly assign each student to either the control group (traditional method) or the experimental group (new method).
  • Implement the teaching methods.
  • Administer a test to all students.
  • Compare the mean scores to see if there's a significant difference.

Problem 2: Blocking Design

(2) A researcher wants to test a new study technique on 100 college students. They know that major and course load can affect grades. How should they set up a blocking design?

Answer
  • Gather data on each student's major and course load.
  • Create blocks based on similar majors and course loads (e.g., biology majors with heavy course loads).
  • Within each block, randomly assign students to either the control group (traditional study technique) or the experimental group (new study technique).
  • Implement the study techniques.
  • Collect grade data and compare the mean grades of the two groups.

Problem 3: Choosing the Right Design

(3) A researcher is considering using a completely randomized design, a blocking design, or a matched pairs design for a study. Explain the advantages and disadvantages of each and recommend the best design for the study described in problem 2.

Answer
  • Completely Randomized Design:

    • Advantage: Simple and easy to implement.
    • Disadvantage: Doesn't control for extraneous variables.
  • Blocking Design:

    • Advantage: Controls for known variables, reduces variability.
    • Disadvantage: Requires more planning.
  • Matched Pairs Design:

    • Advantage: Controls for individual differences, reduces variability.
    • Disadvantage: Can be time-consuming and may not be feasible with large groups.
  • Recommendation: For the study in problem 2, a blocking design is best. It allows the researcher to control for major and course load, which are known to affect grades, while still being feasible with a larger group of students.


Common Mistake

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Confusing blocking with stratification: Blocking is used in experiments, while stratification is used in sampling.
  • Not randomizing within blocks: Always randomize treatments within each block.
  • Using matched pairs when it's not appropriate: Matched pairs are for comparing two treatments on very similar units.

Memory Aid

Memory Aids

  • CRD (Completely Randomized Design): Think "Completely Random, Done!" - It's the simplest, just randomize.
  • Blocking: "Block it out!" - Block out the unwanted variation by grouping similar units.
  • Matched Pairs: "Pair up!" - Pair up similar units to reduce variability.

Final Exam Focus

  • High-Priority Topics:
    • Identifying the correct experimental design given a scenario.
    • Understanding the purpose of blocking and matched pairs.
    • Explaining how to randomize in different designs.
  • Common Question Types:
    • Multiple-choice questions that test your understanding of design differences.
    • Free-response questions that require you to design an experiment.
    • Questions that ask you to identify the best design for a given situation.

Exam Tip

Last-Minute Tips: * Read carefully: Pay close attention to the details of each scenario. * Plan your time: Don't spend too long on any one question. * Show your work: Even if you don't get the right answer, you can get partial credit for showing your process.


Practice Question

Practice Questions

Multiple Choice Questions

(1) A researcher is studying the effect of a new fertilizer on tomato yield. They have 20 tomato plants and randomly assign 10 plants to receive the new fertilizer and 10 to receive the standard fertilizer. What type of experimental design is this?

(A) Completely Randomized Design
(B) Blocking Design
(C) Matched Pairs Design
(D) Stratified Design
(E) Cluster Design

(2) A pharmaceutical company is testing a new drug to lower blood pressure. They recruit 100 participants and measure their blood pressure before and after taking the drug. What type of experimental design is this?

(A) Completely Randomized Design
(B) Blocking Design
(C) Matched Pairs Design
(D) Stratified Design
(E) Cluster Design

(3) A researcher wants to compare two different methods of teaching reading. They have 50 students, and they know that some students have learning disabilities. They decide to group students with learning disabilities together and then randomly assign students within each group to one of the two teaching methods. What type of experimental design is this?

(A) Completely Randomized Design
(B) Blocking Design
(C) Matched Pairs Design
(D) Stratified Design
(E) Cluster Design
Answers

(1) A (2) C (3) B


Free Response Question

A researcher is interested in studying the effect of different types of music on test performance. They recruit 60 students and have them take a math test while listening to one of three types of music: classical, pop, or no music. The researcher knows that students' math skills vary, so they want to control for this variable.

(a) Describe how the researcher could use a completely randomized design to conduct this study.

(b) Describe how the researcher could use a blocking design to conduct this study, controlling for students' math skills.

(c) Which of these two designs would be more appropriate for this study? Justify your answer.

Scoring Guidelines

(a) Completely Randomized Design (2 points)

*   **1 point:** Randomly assign each of the 60 students to one of the three music conditions (classical, pop, or no music).
*   **1 point:** Explain that each student has an equal chance of being assigned to any of the three groups.

(b) Blocking Design (3 points)

*   **1 point:** Assess students' math skills (e.g., using a pre-test or previous grades).
*   **1 point:** Divide students into blocks based on math skills (e.g., high, medium, low).
*   **1 point:** Within each block, randomly assign students to one of the three music conditions.

(c) Justification (2 points)

*   **1 point:** The blocking design is more appropriate.
*   **1 point:** Justification: Blocking controls for the variability in math skills, which may affect test performance. This reduces the influence of the confounding variable (math skill) and provides a more precise estimate of the effect of music on test performance.

Remember, you've got this! Keep practicing, and you'll be an experimental design pro in no time! ๐ŸŒŸ

Question 1 of 11

A researcher randomly assigns 30 participants into three groups: one group gets a new medication, one gets a placebo, and one gets the standard treatment. What type of experimental design is this? ๐Ÿงช

Completely Randomized Design

Blocking Design

Matched Pairs Design

Stratified Design