zuai-logo

Challenges of Political and Social Cleavages

William Gray

William Gray

8 min read

Listen to this study note

Study Guide Overview

This study guide covers political and social cleavages, focusing on their impact on government and society. Key concepts include how cleavages like ethnicity, religion, and class affect governmental legitimacy, conflict, and external interference. It also examines state responses to cleavages and reviews core unit concepts such as civil society, political culture, and civil liberties/rights.

AP Comparative Government: Unit 3 - Challenges of Political and Social Cleavages ๐Ÿงฉ

Hey there, future AP Gov superstar! ๐ŸŒŸ Ready to tackle Unit 3? This guide is your secret weapon for acing the exam, especially if you're reviewing the night before. Let's dive in!

Remember, Unit 3 is all about the dynamic between the state and society. It's a biggie, so make sure you've got these concepts down!

Unit 3: Navigating Political and Social Cleavages ๐Ÿงญ

3.9: The Nitty-Gritty of Political and Social Cleavages

Okay, so we know cleavages are those internal divisions โ€“ think ethnicity, religion, class, geography, etc. โ€“ that can become political. But how do they actually mess with governments? Let's break it down:

How Cleavages Shake Things Up ๐ŸŒช๏ธ

  • Conflicting Interests and Competition ๐Ÿ†š
    • Groups with different interests start vying for power. This can lead to political polarization, but it can also be resolved through dialogue and negotiation. Think of it like a tug-of-war between different groups. ๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ
Key Concept

Coinciding cleavages (when multiple cleavages overlap) can lead to really complex conflicts. Keep an eye out for this concept!

- *Example:* The Zapatista Movement in Mexico emerged partly due to the NAFTA agreement, highlighting conflicts between indigenous groups and those favoring global market integration.
![Zapatista Movement](https://zupay.blob.core.windows.net/resources/files/0baca4f69800419293b4c75aa2870acd_4d8e25_3858.jpeg?alt=media&token=285f5b0c-439c-4cda-b91f-8c04718446a6)
  • Erosion of Governmental Authority and Legitimacy ๐Ÿคจ

    • When cleavages become intense, people might start questioning the government's authority. They might even want more autonomy or complete separation. It's like the government losing its grip.
    • Example: The push for Scottish independence in the UK is a prime example. Historical and cultural differences, combined with Brexit tensions, fuel the desire for autonomy.

    Scottish Independence

  • Escalation to Conflict, Terrorism, and Civil War โš ๏ธ

    • Sometimes, cleavages can get really nasty. Groups might resort to violence, terrorism, or even civil war. It's the extreme end of the spectrum.
    • Example: Boko Haram in Nigeria is a tragic example of a group exploiting cleavages to gain power and inflict violence, aiming to establish a government based on Sharia law.

    Boko Haram

  • External Interference ๐Ÿ˜ง

    • When a government looks weak due to internal divisions, other countries might try to take advantage. This could mean annexing territory or other forms of interference. It's like a pack of wolves circling a weakened prey.
    • Example: Russia's invasion of Ukraine is a stark example of a neighboring state exploiting perceived weakness and vulnerability.

    Russia-Ukraine War

Memory Aid

Cleavages = โž— Divisions: Remember, cleavages are like dividing lines within a country. They can cause a lot of political drama!

State Reactions to Cleavages

States react differently to cleavages. Some might use brute force, while others might try to accommodate minorities. How a state reacts can seriously impact its legitimacy (how much the citizens respect its authority). Authoritarian states tend to be much harsher in dealing with cleavages than democratic states.

Unit 3 - Quick Review! ๐Ÿค“

This unit is all about the back-and-forth between the state and its people. Here's a quick recap:

  • Civil Society ๐Ÿ™‹โ€โ™‚๏ธ: These are the voluntary groups that help people connect with the government. Think of them as the intermediaries between the people and the state.

  • Political Culture, Ideologies, and Beliefs ๐Ÿ’ญ: These are the core values that shape how people think about the government and the balance between order and liberty. ๐Ÿ†“

  • Political Participation: How people engage in politics, both formally (voting) and informally (protesting). Remember that authoritarian and democratic regimes have very different approaches to political participation.

  • Civil Liberties and Civil Rights ๐Ÿ’ช: These are the freedoms and protections that citizens have. Again, authoritarian and democratic regimes differ wildly in how they approach these.

  • Cleavages: The internal divisions that can become politicized and cause tension between groups and the state.

Exam Tip

Connect the dots! AP questions often combine multiple concepts from this unit. For example, how do civil liberties relate to political participation in different regime types?

Practice Questions

Practice Question

Multiple Choice Questions:

  1. Which of the following best describes a coinciding cleavage? (A) A division based on a single factor, such as religion. (B) A division where multiple social factors reinforce each other. (C) A division that is easily resolved through negotiation. (D) A division that only exists in authoritarian regimes.

  2. A state's legitimacy is most directly affected by which of the following? (A) The size of its military (B) The number of political parties (C) The degree to which citizens believe it is acting lawfully (D) The amount of natural resources it possesses

Free Response Question (FRQ):

Prompt: Explain how political and social cleavages can lead to instability within a state. In your response, provide specific examples from two different countries studied in the AP Comparative Government course.

Scoring Guidelines:

*   **Point 1: Identification of Cleavages (1 point)**
    *   The response identifies at least two types of political or social cleavages (e.g., ethnic, religious, class, regional).
*   **Point 2: Explanation of Instability (2 points)**
    *   The response explains how these cleavages can contribute to political instability, such as conflict, polarization, or decreased legitimacy.
*   **Point 3: Example 1 (2 points)**
    *   The response provides a specific example from one country studied in the course where cleavages have led to instability.
    *   The example must include both the type of cleavage and its effect on the country.
*   **Point 4: Example 2 (2 points)**
    *   The response provides a specific example from a second country studied in the course where cleavages have led to instability.
    *   The example must include both the type of cleavage and its effect on the country.

Example Answer:

Political and social cleavages, such as ethnic and religious divisions, can lead to significant instability within a state. These divisions often result in conflicting interests and competition among groups, which can lead to political polarization and a decrease in governmental legitimacy. For example, in Nigeria, the religious cleavage between the predominantly Muslim north and the Christian south has fueled ongoing conflict and violence, such as the actions of Boko Haram, which has undermined the government's authority and stability. In the United Kingdom, the regional cleavage between Scotland and the rest of the UK has led to increased calls for Scottish independence, especially after the Brexit vote, which has created political uncertainty and instability. These examples demonstrate how cleavages can destabilize states by fostering conflict and undermining governmental legitimacy.

Common Mistake

Don't just list cleavages! Explain how they impact governments and societies. The 'why' is crucial.

Final Exam Focus ๐ŸŽฏ

Okay, you're in the home stretch! Hereโ€™s what to prioritize:

  • Cleavages and their impacts: Be ready to discuss how different types of cleavages affect political stability, legitimacy, and conflict.
  • State responses to cleavages: Understand the range of responses, from repression to accommodation, and their consequences.
  • The interplay between state and society: Remember how civil society, political culture, and participation all interact with the state.
Exam Tip

Time management is key! If you're stuck on a question, move on and come back to it later. Don't get bogged down.

Last-Minute Tips ๐Ÿ’ก

  • Read questions carefully! Pay attention to keywords and what the question is actually asking.
  • Use specific examples! Don't just talk in generalities. Use the case studies you've learned.
  • Stay calm! You've got this! Take deep breaths and trust your preparation.

Good luck, you're going to do great! ๐ŸŽ‰

Question 1 of 11

What are political and social cleavages? ๐Ÿค”

External conflicts between states

Divisions within a society that can become politically relevant

Agreements between different groups in society

The absence of conflict in a nation