Evaluating objections, implications, and limitations of different perspectives or arguments

Ryan Hall

6 min read

Study Guide Overview

This AP Research study guide covers evaluating arguments, focusing on identifying appeals (core values, emotions, biases, assumptions, logic), and evaluating argument validity and usefulness. It explores objections, implications, and limitations within arguments. The guide also provides tips for the AP exam, including common question types, high-value topics like logical fallacies and evidence strength, and time management strategies. Practice questions on appeals, validity, and limitations are included.

#AP Research: Evaluating Arguments - Your Ultimate Guide

Hey there, future scholar! Let's get real about arguments. Not all of them are created equal, and your job is to be a savvy evaluator. This guide will help you dissect arguments like a pro, so you can not only ace the exam but also write a killer research paper. Let's dive in!

#What's the Appeal? 🤔

Arguments aren't just about facts; they're about persuasion. Before you dive into the nitty-gritty, figure out what an argument is trying to sell you.

Ask yourself: What does this argument want me to believe?

Here are some common appeals:

Core Values: Appeals to things like freedom, democracy, justice, and morality.
Emotions: Pulls at your heartstrings to sway your feelings.
Personal Biases: Plays on your existing beliefs and preferences.
Assumptions: Relies on unstated preconceptions or beliefs. Example: "9/10 dentists recommend..." assumes dentists are the ultimate authority on toothpaste.
Logic: Claims to be the only rational choice, but don't be fooled—logical-sounding arguments can still be flawed.

Exam Tip

It's not bad for arguments to use appeals, but it can make it harder to evaluate the actual claims, evidence, and reasoning. Be aware of how these appeals might be influencing you.

#Playing Devil's Advocate 😈

Once you've spotted the appeals, consider how they might affect your own biases. Try to see the argument from an opposing viewpoint. This can be tough, but it's a valuable skill. You don't need to do this for every argument, but it's good practice for the big ones.

#Evaluation Questions 🧐

Evaluating arguments can feel like a maze, but her...

How are we doing?

Give us your feedback and let us know how we can improve