Examining how counterargument or alternative perspectives affect an argument

Caleb Thomas
8 min read
Listen to this study note
Study Guide Overview
This AP English Language study guide covers counterarguments and alternative perspectives to strengthen arguments, focusing on the Synthesis and Argument FRQs. It defines these key terms, provides examples, and explains their importance for demonstrating critical thinking and qualifying arguments. The guide also includes a final exam focus section covering high-value topics like thesis construction and rhetorical strategies, common question types, and last-minute tips.
#AP English Language: Mastering Counterarguments and Alternative Perspectives
Hey there, future AP Lang rockstar! π This guide is your secret weapon for acing the Synthesis and Argument essays. We're diving into how to make your arguments super strong by using counterarguments and alternative perspectives. Let's get started!
# Introduction
This guide will help you amp up your arguments, making them more complex and critical. We'll show you how to use counterarguments and alternative perspectives to earn that coveted sophistication point on the Synthesis and Argument FRQs. Remember, these two essays make up two-thirds of your FRQ score, so let's nail them!
# Definitions: Counterarguments vs. Alternative Perspectives
Let's break down these key terms:
- Counterargument: An argument that opposes your main argument. It challenges your argument's validity and highlights its weaknesses. Think of it as playing devil's advocate. π
- Alternative Perspective: A different viewpoint or interpretation of the same topic. It doesn't necessarily oppose your argument but offers a different angle. It's like looking at the same picture from a different perspective. πΌοΈ
#Ice Cream Example
Let's use a simple example to illustrate the difference:
- Argument: Ice cream is the best summertime dessert.
- Counterargument: Many other delicious desserts can be enjoyed in the summer, like frozen yogurt, sorbet, or fruit cobbler. Some people might also avoid dairy, making ice cream unsuitable.
- Alternative Perspective: Some people may prefer savory snacks like chips or cold drinks like lemonade during the summer.
#2021 FRQ #1 Example
Let's look at a more AP-relevant example using the 2021 FRQ #1 about handwriting instruction. You can find the sources here.
- Argument: βEven though it may seem old-fashioned, handwriting should still be taught in schools today.β
- Counterargument: Handwriting instruction takes up valuable time that could be used to teach more relevant skills.
- Alternative Perspective: Handwriting instruction can reinforce other skills like spelling, grammar, and punctuation, and help students develop their unique writing style. π‘
Remember, it's not enough to just mention a counterargument or alternative perspective. You need to elaborate on it, either refuting the counterargument or connecting the alternative perspective to your own argument to strengthen it.
#Quick Self-Check Exercise
Before moving on, quickly think about a counterargument and alternative p...

How are we doing?
Give us your feedback and let us know how we can improve